Atmane Tazaghart
Atmane Tazaghart
Exclusive Survey

Ban on the Muslim Brotherhood: 53% of French People in Favor of Banning MB-Affiliated Organizations

Atmane Tazaghart
Atmane Tazaghart

According to an exclusive poll conducted by Ifop for the magazine Screen Watch, published by Global Watch Analysis, a majority of French people are in favor of banning organizations linked to the Muslim Brotherhood. Among French citizens of Muslim faith, opinions are divided. The idea is viewed favorably by 48% of Muslims in France, who believe it could reduce the grounds for conflating Islam with Islamism. However, 41% fear that such a ban would lead to a form of discrimination against Muslims as a whole.

What strategy would be most effective in addressing entryism tactics of the Muslim Brotherhood? In the Arab world, several countries—including Egypt, the United Arab Emirates, and Saudi Arabia—have banned the Islamist Brotherhood. In the West, matters are more complex: the European and American branches of the MB deny any ties with the parent organization. This complicates legal proceedings against them, as was the case in 2017 when the Trump administration attempted, for the first time, to ban Tanzim al-Dawli, the international body of the Muslim Brotherhood. This did not prevent the U.S. president from renewing, last October, his intention to ban the Muslim Brotherhood. Several states, such as Texas and California, have also taken action, in last November and December, by banning the political and financial activities of the Islamist Brotherhood within their territories.

In France, the idea is gaining ground. According to this poll conducted by Ifop for ‘‘Screen Watch’’ (survey carried out in August and September among two samples: 1,005 people of Muslim faith and 1,000 people representative of the French population as a whole), 53% of the French population approve of banning the Muslim Brotherhood-affiliated organizations. Among Muslims in France, opinions are divided: 38% are in favor, 43% are opposed, and 19% have no clear opinion on the issue.

GWA

GWA

Those who oppose it among French Muslims do not all do so for “bad reasons”: 41% fear that such a ban would lead to “a form of discrimination against Islam and Muslims as a whole,” while 31% worry that it would “encourage the emergence of Islamist movements even more radical.”

By contrast, nearly one out of two French Muslims has a positive a priori view of banning the Muslim Brotherhood-affiliated organizations: 48% of Muslims in France believe that banning the Muslim Brotherhood could “reduce the grounds for conflating Islam with Islamism”; 47% believe that such a ban would “strengthen national cohesion and respect for the laws”; and 36% think it would “help curb communitarianism.”

GWA

GWA